top of page

Do Spices Expire or Just Fade?

2 days ago
6 min read

Glass jars of herbs, spices, and seasonings on a wooden shelf

Caption: Glass jars of herbs, spices, and seasonings on a wooden shelf


Do Spices Expire or Just Fade?

Spices don't expire. They just fade. As long as they stay dry, they don't spoil the way milk or meat does, and they won't make you sick. That old jar of paprika in the back of your cupboard is safe to eat. It just won't do much for your ribs.


Spices get their flavor and smell from volatile oils (natural oils that evaporate easily). As those oils evaporate, the aroma and flavor go with them, and you end up seasoning with color and texture only. How long that takes depends on whether the spice is whole or ground and how you store it.


What this article covers

How Long Do Spices Last?

Whole spices last the longest because their oils stay sealed inside until you grind them. Grinding opens those oils to the air, so ground spices fade sooner than whole spices.


Each type of spice has its own timeline before it loses its flavor. These timelines are guidelines, not rules, however. But if you store them well, then they should last up to 4 years for whole spices.


Type

Good Flavour For

Examples

Whole spices

About 3 to 4 years

Peppercorns, cumin seed, cinnamon sticks, whole cloves

Ground spices

About 2 to 3 years

Ground cumin, paprika, chili powder, garlic powder

Blends and rubs

About 1 to 2 years

BBQ rubs, taco seasoning, steak blends

Blends fade the fastest because they mix several ground spices, so they fade as fast as the most delicate spice in them.


For example, a rub could mix ground cumin, which lasts 2 to 3 years, with dried oregano, which fades sooner. By year two, the cumin still tastes strong, but the oregano has lost its flavor, so the rub tastes dull. That's why blends get 1 to 2 years.


If you're worried about your spices fading, buy smaller jars, so you use them up before the flavor goes.


Spices in bowl on a wooden table

Caption: Spices in bowl on a wooden table


Trust Your Nose and Eyes Over the Jar Date

Trust your nose over the date on the jar. The best-by date assumes you store your spices correctly. If you left it next to the stove, it might have faded sooner than if you'd stored it in a cool, dark place.


Shake a small amount into your palm and rub it between your fingers. A fresh spice smells strong right away. If you have to put your nose right up to it to smell anything, it's faded.


Check the color as well. Paprika and chili powder should be a deep red, and dried herbs should be green. Brick-brown paprika or gray herbs have faded.


A faded spice won't hurt you, but you'll need more of it to get any flavor. If it's a rub, the salt doesn't fade, only the spices do. Using more of it to make up for the weak flavor can leave your meat too salty.


Heat, Light, and Moisture: Storing Your Blends

Keep your spices away from heat, light, and moisture. Heat makes the flavor oils evaporate faster. Light fades the color. Moisture makes spices clump, and enough of it can grow mold.


The shelf above the stove or smoker is the worst spot in the kitchen, even though it's the handiest, because it gets the most heat and steam.


To keep your blends fresh:


  • Keep rubs in airtight jars and close the lid right after you use them, so air and moisture stay out.

  • Store them in a cool, dark cupboard or drawer, away from the stove, the dishwasher, and sunny areas.

  • If your rub comes in a shaker, shake it into your hand or a bowl first, not straight over a steaming pot or a hot grill. Steam can get into the shaker and make the rub clump.

  • If you prefer to scoop your rub out of a jar, use a dry spoon every time. One damp spoon can turn the whole jar into a hard clump.

We recommend seasoning your meat at the counter, away from the grill, so steam stays out of your rub. A prep tub (a collapsible tub that holds your meat while you season it) is the perfect spot for that, since it holds the loose rub and the raw meat juices in one place. DDR BBQ Supply is our go-to for prep tubs and other BBQ essentials like thermometers and tongs.


Beasley's rubs in airtight containers

Caption: Beasley's rubs in airtight containers


Why All-Natural Blends Clump

Even if you store your rub well, it can clump on a humid day. That's normal for an all-natural blend, and it's easy to fix.


What Anti-Caking Agents Do

Many supermarket seasonings contain anti-caking agents (ingredients added to keep a blend loose), like silicon dioxide or calcium silicate. They soak up stray moisture and coat the spice particles, so the blend keeps pouring freely, even on a humid day. If you care about all-natural ingredients, you might not want them in your rub.


We don't put any anti-caking agents or other additives in our rubs, so everything in the jar is something you'd find in your own kitchen. Salt, garlic, and onion pull moisture out of the air, so on a humid day an all-natural rub can clump.


But just because the seasoning has clumped a little doesn't mean you've lost any flavor. All you need to do is break up the clump, and you can get cooking with tasty, all-natural ingredients.


The Rice or Dry Bean Fix

To fix a clumpy rub, drop a small spoonful of uncooked rice or a few dry beans into the jar. They soak up moisture, so the rub stays loose, and can also knock clumps apart when you shake the jar. It's an old kitchen trick.


If the holes in your shaker lid are big, use beans. Rice grains can fall out with the rub. If you scoop your rub out of a jar, pick the rice or beans out first so they don't end up in your food.


For a stubborn lump, tap it with a spoon or break it up in a dry spice grinder.


Uncooked white rice in a sack

Caption: Uncooked white rice in a sack


How Beasley's Got Started

It all started at church, where we cooked for big crowds every week. One day, a groom asked us to cater his wedding, so we brought our smoked brisket.


The compliments were nice, but what caught our eye was the guests who kept going back to the buffet, piling their plates high, and sneaking them out the front door, right past the pastor. We ended up hiding some brisket so the bride and groom could take some home. That's when we knew our rub was a winner.


And in 2018, we founded Beasley's Smokehouse Rub.


What's in a Beasley's Blend

Our blends are all natural, gluten-free, and made without MSG. You can pronounce every ingredient on the label, so you know exactly what's going on your meat.


Our salt content is lower than most comparable supermarket brands, but it's still enough to bring out the flavor of your meat. We keep it lower on purpose, so you taste the spices first and can add more salt yourself if you want it.


Four of our blends contain sugar. If you're ever unsure whether a rub is sweet or savory, look for sugar in the ingredient list.


This weekend, give your spice drawer a sniff test and toss the jars that smell like nothing. Then replace them with fresh jars of the blends you cook with most.


Frequently asked questions

Do all-natural rubs lose their flavor faster than store-bought ones?

No. Anti-caking agents only keep a blend from clumping, so leaving them out doesn't change how fast the flavor fades. Flavor loss depends on the spices and how you store them.

Why does my sweet rub clump faster than my savory one?

Sugar pulls moisture out of the air, just like salt, garlic, and onion do. A sweet rub has sugar on top of those, so it pulls in more moisture faster on a humid day than rubs that just contain salt and garlic.

Can I keep my rub jar next to the smoker during a long cook?

Pour what you'll need into a small bowl and send the sealed jar back to a cool, dark cupboard. Heat and smoky humidity at the pit will drain its flavour quickly.

Can I store my spices in the fridge or freezer?

No. Keep them in a cool, dark cupboard instead. When you take a cold jar out into a warmer kitchen, moisture forms on it, and moisture makes spices clump.


 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page